in Internet Marketing by Jeffrey_Smith

After experimenting with a few brand new keyword specific niche sites as personal SEO project for the past 90 days, the question came up, does a site really need backlinks as much as before? and if so, how many does it need to cross the tipping point?.
niche-sites
After posting niche-specific quality content (gleaned from intensive keyword research) each day for 7 days a week and building less than 100 links to the site:

  • The site now ranks for over 400 unique keywords both competitive and long-tail keywords in the top 10 and top 20 results of Google, Yahoo and MSN
  • Has attracted over 1800 visits from 1100 unique visitors its first month (and is increasing traffic, impressions and user engagement daily).

The site has had no advertising or promotion (aside from the few links it has), is relatively brand new and ranks next to well established brand names just from a few posts that mention them in the title.

In addition, the site gets indexed within minutes of posting fresh content and has all of the trappings of a well established authority site (which would have taken years) to acquire the same level of trust, yet the site is not even 90 days old.

To say that this was alarming and quite amazing was an understatement. At this rate, by the time this website is 8 months old, it should rank for the one word trophy phrase for the entire industry (which equates to a feasible amount of traffic / monetization potential).

So, my argument is, can site architecture and earmarked content accomplish more than just link building or just link building without content? in this case, absolutely! The only thing different in this study was two things.

The first is, it was almost like the shotgun approach to SEO vs. the laser beam approach I was used to employing in regard to SEO in the past. It’s tricky when dealing with sites that have already been branded or limited by their content or lack of it (history can help your efforts or hurt them, depending on positioning).

The second thing was to start fresh with a new site, select the pinnacle phrases in advance then built semantic bridges to support the disparity in the gap using titles, internal links and tags augmented by RSS and site architecture.

This is one clear case that starting fresh and not making the mistakes of an aged site can magnify the themes on page / off page coherence. In essence, by creating the peaks and valleys and controlling the conversation, we could dictate how search engines would interpret the content and then add its own variations of keyword stemming to the mix. This also needed less coaxing (if you will) to convince search engines about the true ranking objective and traction the site was targeting.

So, instead of the old approach of walking into an established site, trying to make it rank for additional phrases and have the process hampered by its history. We were able to forgo this process and jump right past 990 other sites (for competitive terms) just by using a clearly delineated site architecture, internal links and using a modified technique of theming and siloing to get the benefit of each post working for a benchmark semantic goal (the competitive root keyword).

As a result, my eyes were opened to an entirely new way to do SEO (ambient traffic that rises). That’s the beauty of this industry, just when you thought you had seen it all, you forgot to test antiquated assumptions to see if they are still valid today.

When discussing this with a friend, his input was, “It’s amazing how much time is spent designing the page for robots, when it is customers who make the decision to buy“. Much in the same way, you can assume you know more then the signals of search and second guess where traffic flows, or you can or you can just test the waters across multiple keywords simultaneously with a niche site to build traffic and website authority when you find a real signal. This method can equate to unbridled rankings with less effort and be replicated with other synonyms with ease.

Does the mini-site / niche site model still work? Absolutely, but now with the ability to gain authority faster than ever (if you provide quality content) this model can challenging and upstage older sites who have become complacent in their ranking and relevance / demeanor.

For the sake of clarity the term niche site in this instance refers to a site based on a very clear topical base of keywords. It may have 200-300 pages, but very targeted pages at that. If qualified traffic is the objective, there are many ways to attract visitors (some more expensive and more time consuming than others). However, do not discount the fact that search engines know more about your niche than you do in most instances, or at least what else they are looking for.

If you observe the trends, listen to the signals of search and pay attention to the medium, then you can leverage it and pick keywords that convert day in an day out by using them as your main topics for discussion.

Search engines can gauge what your site is about and send more traffic from keywords you never even considered (just from briefly mentioning them), if you get out of your own way and let them do what they do best (deliver traffic). The traditional SEO is now something you use to steer the reigns once you find which keywords have the most search volume.

The takeaway is, instead of trying to make a square peg fit in a round hole and trying to make a site rank for a specific keywords, you can create a new site, use targeted content to rank for everything in between the semantic signals, then use SEO to lean in to the keywords and phrases with the highest engagement and search volume to monetize traffic. 

Read More Related Posts
Is Using Keyword-Rich Domains a Solid SEO Strategy?
What are the strategic SEO advantages of having a relevant keyword-rich domain name? Is it a temporal search engine loophole or viable long-term ranking strategy? They say what is but a ...
READ MORE
SEO Tips to Develop a Tactical Game Plan
Websites do not optimize themselves; they need SEO, a game plan and tactful execution to overcome savvy competitor’s intent on ranking in the top 3 results for any respective profit-bearing ...
READ MORE
SEO Tips to Take Usability & Design to The Next Level
What is the point of driving traffic to a website if you send them away from bad design once they get there? Sure, SEO is important but so is usability, ...
READ MORE
How do Term Frequency and Inverse Document Frequency Determine Relevance?
To understand SEO, you need to understand two things (1) the search behavior of motivated buyers and (2) what search engines deem relevant. Common sense coupled with insight to the ...
READ MORE
Are you stuck on page 2 or worse?
What are a few viable SEO solutions you can use when your search engine optimization efforts "stall out" and your targeted keywords are trapped past page 2 and simply won’t ...
READ MORE
How to Dethrone Competitors using SEMRush, Compete, SpyFu and Alexa.
Looking for a quick way to data mine competitors keywords to determine if they are worth the hassle to optimize? After reading this quick SEO tip and using a few ...
READ MORE
Web Site Analysis
When using SEO to develop relevance for competitive keywords for your website, just remember that everybody starts at zero. Granted, initiating your campaign with a thorough web site analysis is crucial, ...
READ MORE
SEO is Not about Excuses, Only Results!
Overcoming competitive markets is one of the most challenging facets of SEO. You are virtually in the trenches duking it out daily pitted against some of the most fierce competition ...
READ MORE
The Rise and Fall of Rankings
Search engine results and their respective positions rarely stand still. In fact, we know from SEO that search results constantly vary, fluctuate, rise and fall, like the tide endlessly churning ...
READ MORE
There is no substitute for doing things right the first time.
The thing to keep in mind about SEO is that it is scalable and depending on (a) your website and if it was constructed initially with SEO in mind (b) ...
READ MORE
Using Keyword-Rich Domains and Subdomains for SEO
SEO Tips for Creating a Strategic Game Plan
SEO Tips to Take Usability & Design to
SEO and Search Engine Algorithms
Rankings Stuck? Try these 5 SEO Tips
SEO Tips to Find Competitors’ Keywords
Web Site Analysis
Overcoming Competitive Markets
The Rise and Fall of Rankings
SEO Expertise is Worth it

About Jeffrey_Smith

In 2006, Jeffrey Smith founded SEO Design Solutions (An SEO Provider who now develops SEO Software for WordPress).

Jeffrey has actively been involved in internet marketing since 1995 and brings a wealth of collective experiences and marketing strategies to increase rankings, revenue and reach.

4 thoughts on “Niche Sites and SEO, Do They Still Work?
  1. Jason says:

    Interesting. Was this SEO experiment done using a WordPress blog site? Do you think it’ll work with a static site?

  2. Jason:

    It was done with a WordPress blog, and frankly the method would take much longer with a static site. The premise is internal linking and fresh links funneling deep links back to the pages with continuity. WordPress is a natural for this with optimized permalinks.

  3. Dave says:

    I’m still not sure how I came across your site, but the more I explore your site the more I am blown away by the insights your share. As someone fairly new and about to build his first niche site, this post grabbed me by the balls…(pardon the language)

    If you have any more words of wisdom or updates regarding this particular project I would love to hear them.

    P.S. By any chance do you have any reading or course material recommendations for someone looking to build sites for themselves to earn an additional monthly income?

Comments are closed.