in SEO by Jeffrey_Smith

If you closely monitor your SEO rankings, from time to time a ripple enters the SERP’s (search engine result pages) and shakes things up a bit in the index. You need to minimize SERP volatility and assess if it was self-induced, algorithmic, or just your competitors challenging you for your most coveted keyword space.

Rankings Slip? Assess Metrics to Minimize SERP Volatility

Rankings Slip? Assess Metrics to Minimize SERP Volatility

Don’t panic if your search engine rankings fall, fluctuations in rankings are often dubbed the Google dance and among other things, there are a number of reasons why this type of phenomenon can occur.

The main consideration is that search engine algorithms are constantly undergoing revisions to stay ahead of things like SEO automation, abuse from spam and other known variables known for obstructing the search engines ability to parse, assess and grade pages with the highest degree of accuracy.

When this occurs, often many of the variables that your rankings are predicated upon can also get caught within this whirlwind of change and fluctuations may occur for a variety of reasons.

Here are some of the most common occurrences and what you can do to insulate yourself.

The Deep Crawl: Depending on the growth rate of indexed content or competition for specific keywords a surge of information, posts, pages and videos may inundate the SERP’s. As a result, Google will parse this information by often cross referencing this data with data from the past.

We dubbed this in house as the search engine shake down and the outward manifestations of this type of deep crawl (where trust and other variables also play a big role in the vacillations) think of it as a litmus test for the new SERPs against the seasoned SERPs which have been in place for months if not years.

This deep crawl can occur once per month or once every two to three months. When it happens, you may see half of your pages fall out of the index or a larger percentage of content take a dip in rankings. Just consider those pages as on the fence and they need additional metrics or reference from other sources (either from within your website or from external sites) to get the regard they had from search engines.

Typically rankings and results will reappear where they were, but the main thing is to consider what changes were made to a site and if anything drastic was done, to document it and or return back to a previous iteration if the situation does not remedy itself over 7-10 days.

Every so often some pages higher up in the food chain lose relevance or forget that the vertical they belong to is competitive. Hence, the more they rest, the more likely their results are to be overthrown by a hungry competitor who wants to occupy their spot.

Getting too comfortable at the top is a mistake that anyone enjoying a top 10  or top 5 search engine position for a competitive keyword should avoid. Remember, post frequency, peer review and internal on page relevance all play a role in keeping results buoyant, and you cannot simply assume that just because you are ranking there today, that something cannot happen and the rules of relevance can change.

The Weekend Index: Although this is merely refined to our own research, we have discovered that sometimes search engines provide different SERPs (search engine results pages) from Friday to Mid Monday. We speculate they do this to compile data and shake out the flimsy results by running a battery of filters to parse questionable content.

Consider this like a type of amnesia where the data center that crawled your page and the other data centers which may or may not have that data populated within their servers can create a “now you see me now you don’t topsy / turvey” effect on individual pages and their ability to aid other pages ranking in the index.

If page C falls out for some reason and Page C was responsible for Ranking Page B and Page A, then Page B and Page A may take a temporal dip until the daisy chain is repaired and the continuity and link flow restored based on indexation. The main thing is NOT to panic, and look for what could have created less weight for Page C (try getting more deep links to the page to remedy link flow).

Deindexation: I have recently compiled a few posts on the topic of over-optimization and de-indexation and ways to stave this type of penalty off or defer it entirely. This is a matter of duplicate content and duplicity or redundancy of content segments occurring across multiple areas within a website.

As the filters get more intelligent, templates need diversity to produce a unique and distinguishable footprint for their shingles (groups of words) that should correspond directly to their title, url naming conventions, h1 tags and internal links from other pages.

Any variance that lacks relevance or is akin to keyword stuffing or having too many common elements across multiple pages is a demotion just waiting to happen (if someone else has the least imperfect score for that keyword).

Unique content is the cornerstone of search engine positioning, the less you have or the less frequently it is updated, the less likely you are going to be able to defend against a more savvy or more determined competitor who is producing quality content, peer review or acquiring quality inbound links.

Quality Raters: These are people whose primary job is to assess the quality of a webpage and or website and how it correlates to the SERPs they currently thrive in. From time to time people such as this take pen and pad and make assessments which can be added to the repository to filter results (like a slight penalty) to individual pages if the Google guidelines are not being adhered to.

You never know which of the variations above have occurred (changes to a site, server problems, changes to algorithms which devalue your pages, a quality rater or competition). What you may try to find out is, was the penalty associated or confined to one keyword, a group of related keywords or has no particular rhyme or reason.

Introduction of New Ranking or Rating Metrics: Things like blended search, personalization and so many other less publicized changes occur on a regular basis. In 2009 Google had well over 400 algorithm updates pertaining to ranking and re-ranking the SERPs; who is to say that that number of revision will slow down for 2010?

We have only scratched the surface of how or why incidents like loss in search engine position can occur. However it can usually be tracked to a correlating event done from within a website on the admin level as opposed to a mere shift in search engine ranking factors. Or on the contrary, you have to let the results play out a bit, until you can find a trail of data to support your theory and solidify a method to reconstruct the relevance a page or series of pages once had.

If it excessive footer links, too many anchors overlapping with the same keywords, the fact that you changed your title and meta tags? got a bad link or a competitor performed negative SEO on your site? You have to let things settle before jumping to conclusions.

More often than naught, results return and it was just the engineers testing a new formula, but you still need to hold on to your hat and not jump to too many conclusions or start changing random elements in an attempt to unwind the penalty or loss in the SERPs. Stay cool, put your thinking cap on and find the questionable construct or take the opportunity to create new content and provide vibrant internal links to slouching segments of a site (if you want those pages to stay indexed, healthy and buoyant with the ability to pass along ranking credits to other pages). 

Read More Related Posts
Many of you may be wondering, what is it that search engines look for in a good design? Why is it, for example that some websites rise to the top ...
We Know, It’s Not Just About SEO
Just like a healthy diet, having a balanced array if nutritional variety serves the overall goal (which is to create holistic health for all functions of the body). Much in ...
SEO, Is It All About Links? Not Anymore
With so many new algorithms being adjusted, modified or replaced altogether, between the cached version of the SERPs (search engine result pages) and the actual index there are obvious discrepancies leaving ...
Puzzled About Landing Page Performance?
The saying you can lead a horse to water, but can’t make them drink is the equivalent of bringing a visitor to a landing page through paid search, banners, contextual ...
How Does SEO Work?
Search Engine Optimization also known as the acronym SEO, is a collection of tactics unified for a common goal. That goal is to streamline inconsistencies within a website from the page ...
SEO for Large Websites Part II
In our first blog post of this 3 part series named SEO for Large Websites Part I, we touched on the importance of defining ranking objectives (from the onset) to ...
Search Engine Mannerisms
When you constantly crawl thousands of search engine result pages daily (just to understand the behavior of cause / effect and the search engine algorithm) you start to notice the ...
SEO and Big Brands…Do they ALL need it?
Let’s say you represent a BIG brand; one that is a household name. Next, let’s say that your products or services are not e-commerce based. Want an example? Sure, let’s ...
SEO Method#1 to Produce Keyword Stemming
Often the effectiveness of search engine optimization is predicated by keywords and SEO rankings. Since this is a primary metric for performance, I would like to share a previously guarded ...
Why Should Search Engines Rank Your Website?
Sounds like a harsh way to start off a blog post about SEO, but in actuality, if you are not promoting an internal page structure or preferred hierarchy from within ...
Search Engine Optimization Using Content, Design, Links &
We Know, It’s Not Just About SEO
SEO, Is It All About Links? Not Anymore
Why Most Landing Pages Fail
How SEO Works
SEO for Large Websites Part II
Search Engine Mannerisms
SEO and Big Brands…Do they ALL need it?
SEO Rankings and How to Create Them
Why Should Search Engines Rank Your Pages?

About Jeffrey_Smith

In 2006, Jeffrey Smith founded SEO Design Solutions (An SEO Provider who now develops SEO Software for WordPress).

Jeffrey has actively been involved in internet marketing since 1995 and brings a wealth of collective experiences and marketing strategies to increase rankings, revenue and reach.

14 thoughts on “My Rankings Fell: Dealing with a Slip in the SERPs
  1. kev grant says:

    Hi Jeffrey, how’s life treating you?

    still watching that weekend index then? is interesting this weekend, can’t work out whether its our new site coming online massively strongly or G’s weekend antics.

    hope its the first..

    keep well my friend ;)

  2. Hey Kev:

    All is well here… Just noticed a slight dip for one of our most prominent keywords and thought I would write a post about it…

    Nothing like a good challenge eh? Seems the weekend index here is rotating a few new guys through our space and all the while indexation is slightly down a bit.

    Things should bounce back, but I have been a bit lax on the post frequency due to being so busy.

    Hope to catch up soon and all the best…

  3. I think that google is changing the algorithm very frequently, Few days ago I get my blog on SERP rank, but now my blog loss the rank.

  4. machim says:

    I enjoyed the article and thanks for this information .

  5. Dee says:

    I have a site that made changes, and for the most part rankings improved to the interior landing pages.

    The PROBLEM is that the 3 most valuable keywords all dropped significantly because they were all relevant for the homepage and not the landing pages.

    Should I change the title tag and H! back on the homepage or give it more time? Why does Google not see the interior landing pages relevant for these keywords like it does with the other keywords?

  6. Justin says:

    Hi Jeffrey,

    Let’s say a site has had a decrease in rankings because of a quality rater, a bad link or something else. If changes are then made to the page/site to correct the problem, do the algorithms notice the correction (or quality raters return to notice the change) so that the site can rank where it once did? Or is it difficult to undo a penalty?

    Thanks for the helpful post.


  7. Christa says:

    Your blog is extremely addictive I’m getting to learn so much i never knew before. When i first launched my blog i started getting some traffic in 2-3 weeks and i was ranking for certain keywords but suddenly one day my rankings went down.I was on the 10-12 page of google search for my keywords.I panicked and thought my site is in Google sandbox but to my surprise i got the ranking back in around 15 days and till then I’m doing quite good.

  8. Writeonbro says:

    You hit the nail on the head! It’s just the G’s way of doing a little dance. Things do always seem to levels off.

  9. Jenn says:

    I realize the Google Dance happens all the time and it has moved my website all over in the SERPS, but, I was ranking on page 5 of Google for a very competative keyword and I unfortunately disappeared to not even being ranked in the top 1000. I am going on the 7th week of my website disappearing. Do you think this is still the Google Dance or something else?

  10. Hard to say, so many variables. If it does not return in 2 weeks, then consider it another type of filter (or perhaps the links linking to you were devalued). If you can’t get that page ranked in your website, you can always boost another page from the same site. Rankings are by the page, and sometimes if a page is penalized, it does not stop other pages from the same site from ranking.

  11. Pranjal says:

    That was real helpful but its not what i was actually looking for!

Comments are closed.