in SEO by Jeffrey_Smith

Everyone talks about authority sites, but how big is too big when it comes to creating rankings? Where is the point where having too much content can cause a website to sag under its own weight and lose relevance?

How Big is Too Big?

How Big is Too Big?

How many pages do you really need online to cross the virtual SEO tipping point for your desired keywords and step into the top 10 spotlight? Is it 200, 2000, 20,000 or 200,000 pages?

There are a surprising number of authority sites replete with high page rank with ten to hundreds of thousands of pages that rank for a virtual cornucopia of mid-tail keywords, but simply can’t parse the top 10 for the top tier competitive one word or two word trophy phrase.

So, aside from sheer size and magnatude alone, what is holding them back?

When Typical Metrics Fail

Is it content, links, structure, or the lack of any of all of those variables? First, you have to understand that rankings take time, and instead of trying to pigeonhole a website or retrofit it into a competitive keyword vertical, you need to integrate purpose from the onset and build a suitable ontology.

Also note, that if left unchecked a site can grow to bulbous amounts of irrelevance and compromise the ability to zero in on specific keywords and key phrases.

When I say purpose, I mean really integrate all of the proper signals to signify to search engines and users alike “through language” that the scope and breadth of your website is capable of creating appeal and facilitating engagement on multiple dimensions.

There is nothing worse than people abusing or wearing out dated SEO techniques such as keyword density (stuffing keywords on a page) in an attempt to fool search engines into scoring or ranking their content higher.

In fact, it is better to have a wider array of topical semantic indicators for your content to facilitate keyword stemming and each page taking on its own persona. You should let the site architecture and internal linking do the heavy lifting and consume your competitive keywords over time.

Finding the Tipping Point then Moving On

Each keyword has a tipping point, but when you manage hundreds or thousands of keywords simultaneously from tactful implementation such as theming and siloing the rules of the game change swiftly.

The idea for each page in your website should be to reach the top 3 rankings for something relevant to that page, the top 10 just isn’t good enough unless you page is above the fold (the top 5 results). This way, each and every page that you add becomes an instant asset that produces short-term value as well as long term gain.

We have become experts at identifying the proper signals of search and giving search engines the proper foundation to nourish relevance. Despite the popular opinion that “it’s all about backlinks”, it’s not; we have sites with less than 500-1000 links ranking for keywords with millions of competing pages in “phrase match” and just a few hundred pages of content.

Ironically, the other sites which occupy the top 10 positions for the same keywords have anywhere from 10 to 20 times the links and or pages to accomplish the same thing; which makes me want to rally back to the point mentioned above.

Don’t let your website get bloated

When is it time to prune a site and extract those signals of trust into something tangible that can dynamically infuse new content with verve and zest? How much is too much when it comes to acquiring a top ranking position?

Do you really need 40K links pointing at one page or 10,000 pages on the same topic to push a keyword to the top? It depends on your approach and how broad your semantic footprint is along the way.

Without going too far into specifics (which you can do by following the links provided in the suggested reading section at the footer of this post), is boils down to cultivating content and authority simultaneously.

But once you acquire that stance in any given vertical or niche, it is almost as if the algorithm spreads out, then becomes buoyant. Meaning, a website has the tendency to extract the range of semantic signals that emanate from the content, fulfill the long-tail and mid-tail rankings as a result of happenstance and unique search queries.

If you don’t believe me, just look at your server logs and see what kind of unique keywords are dropping off traffic to your pages. It is not surprising that most websites receive 20% of their traffic from their top 10 most prominent keywords and the remaining 80% of their traffic from mid-tail and long-tail keyword variations.

Naturally over time, websites have a tendency to move up to acquire more competitive keywords and respective phrases, but not magically of their own accord (they need guidance and sculpting like clay). The entire process sometimes happens so gradually that you may or may not know that it is happening.

This ascent of relevance is the process of homogenization whereby the fusion of pages, content, links, popularity and engagement all produce a unique signal. First you may have 20-30 visits per day, then 50-100, before you know it your site is attracting thousands of visitors per day as each page passes the threshold of relevance.

If you understand that this synergy is a systematic reaction based on cause and effect it is possible to augment specific outcomes based on a structured series of preferences (such as toppling a competitive keyword).

Understanding the Hierarchy of Relevance

Before you run, you must learn to crawl and then learn to walk and in this instance, the analogy refers to understanding how the tip of the iceberg is extremely important to cultivate. Your topic is the apex and the content you use to shore it up should also contain relevant pears to tie the theme together.

With the vast array of information available at break neck speeds, there are no shortages of options for users online. The takeaway here is, stay on topic, but learn to see past just trying to rank for keywords. Ultimately it is about dominating market share, attention and conversion when it boils down to commerce.

Social media is great as the glue, but search engines prefer structure and keeping balance when assessing on page and off page signals of relevance.

Now for Solutions

  • Dated content from the past is a treasure trove to extract ranking factor. You can look for its degree of impact and if it still serves the purpose of your website or brand or recycle that link equity into laser-like sub domains or site segments to receive dividends tenfold.
  • To infuse new pages with vitality just create a link from an old page to the new page with a keyword rich anchor (preferably closer to the top of the page). This is called virtual theming and the less links you have leaving a page the better.
  • Try to avoid redundancy in titles, tags or taxonomy. After seeing the same content, a barren page barely capable of being distinguishable as unique aside from the same shingles in the template is only going to make search engines give up.
  • The more unique each page is, the better, as long as the parent theme is nurtured. This is where images (with keyword rich alt attributes can be used, or secondary navigation, breadcrumbs or footer links can aid SEO).
  • Sweep your site for broken links and outbound links and seal them up with nofollow tags, or just use noindex, follow or the robots txt file to block link loss from sapping your internal pages. This applies to dated and less relevant content (so you can spend your link equity wisely).
  • Keep your content unique and look for the commercial value of harnessing present-tense videos in place of long, drawn out text to revitalize dated pages of use them as springboards to newer, fresher content.
  • If you know a page is ranking for a competitive keyword, rewrite or re-purpose the content with a video or a call to action above the fold instead to funnel that traffic to a more appropriate region for conversion.
  • Make sure each page gets a share of the link flow in a site. No need to choke of regions from lack of links.
  • If you have Google Webmaster Tools installed, you can always look at the internal link percentages to see if your pages have a balanced link profile (both internal and external links).
  • The more pages you have, the more opportunity your site has to hemorrhage relevance. Content is a double edged sword, it can work for you or against you when it comes to rankings.
  • If there is too much of the same (in the titles or tags), then search engines will trim the fat and de-index redundant pages.
  • On the contrary, if those pages are pulling decent traffic, then you may want to reconsider using them another way as hub pages to segue consumers to higher ground (such as a category page presented with enticing offers).
  • Use sitemaps and deep link to them to spread link flow to pages in need. This alone can ensure SERP (search engine result page) longevity for larger websites which have the need to supplement buoyancy and augment hang time in search engines.
  • Minimize the use of URL parameters when possible or implement pretty URL’s closer to the root folder to improve ranking position.
  • Instead of being a victim of a rigid CMS, use rewrites as a proxy to position each page as a relevant destination.
  • Ensure there are sufficient deep links to critical pages (5 or more) to get a page on the map and when you reach over a few hundred links pointing at an individual page, then those links can transcend the anchor text and act like a ranking credit to augment other pages in the site.
  • The more pages you have, the less links each page needs to rank for something. Keep content fresh and build a relationship with the spiders. The fresh content and fresh link factor make a difference.
  • While it may be fine to let certain pages age and gain authority like fine wine, keep adding new content regularly and link to aged content to entice search engines.
  • You can leverage the power of RSS feeds to accomplish this #5 and #7 simultaneously as well as to encourage search engine spiders to crawl deeper and keep stemmed results relevant and vertically mobile.

Suggested Reading

Thanks for visiting, if you have not already, make sure to subscribe to the RSS feed to receive SEO tips,  SEO training, SEO Videos and Techniques from SEO Design Solutions™

Read More Related Posts
SEO Link Building – How to Achieve Multiple Top 10 Rankings with the SEO Domino Effect!
Ranking in the top 10 search results is accomplished frequently through building links from authority sites in conjunction with exceptional on-page factors. By understanding the premise of how and which ...
SEO Tools: Looking Back to Move Forward!
Sometimes, especially with SEO tools, you've got to go back to move forward. I recently stumbled accross this old video of myself and my good friend Matt Da Cruz from 3 ...
Optimizing Titles and Descriptions for On Page Continuity
Despite our best predictions with SEO, you can never pin-point with accuracy which keywords from a title tag, meta description or combined occurrence of a keyword on a page search ...
SEO or Conversion Optimization?
What's the point of having a website if you don't have traffic? Sure, SEO can attract visitors but what good is that in the long-run if that traffic does not ...
You've Got Traffic, Now What?
The natural assumption is that SEO involves just choosing a few keywords, making a few changes and presto, your website magically appears in the top 10 results (preferably in the ...
Scale or ...
The only difference between and market-dominant authority site (replete with SEO), a keyword-sniping niche site, a vast shopping cart filled with thousands products or a blog is scope, scale, resource ...
Gaining Attention/Market Share through Value Based Conversion
In an attempt to corner “the attention market”, utilizing competitive market intelligence in tandem with practical investigation one can increase the trajectory of happenstance to funnel traffic and engagement to ...
How SEO Really Works!
SEO involves a combination of on page and off page factors which produce a distinct effect (a higher ranking for specific exact match and broad match shingles). Therefore, instead of ...
Finding the Proper Balance of SEO
Finding the proper SEO ratios for content, links and competing pages is critical for determining where each keyword fits in the hierarchy. This correlation between site architecture, URL, title, internal ...
Finding the Right SEO Company for the Best SEO Services
Search engine optimization otherwise known as SEO, is comprised of multiple disciplines. Each has its roots in improving a websites performance by streamlining facets ranging from site and information architecture, ...
SEO Link Building – How to Achieve Multiple
SEO Tools: Looking Back to Move Forward!
Optimizing Meta Titles and Descriptions
SEO or Conversion Optimization?
SEO is Great, But What Happens Next?
SEO Reality Check! Scope, Scale, Resource and Intent
Gaining Attention/Market Share through Value Based Conversion
How SEO Really Works!
SEO Ratios for Content, Links and Competing Pages
Finding the Right SEO Company for the Best

About Jeffrey_Smith

In 2006, Jeffrey Smith founded SEO Design Solutions (An SEO Provider who now develops SEO Software for WordPress).

Jeffrey has actively been involved in internet marketing since 1995 and brings a wealth of collective experiences and marketing strategies to increase rankings, revenue and reach.

7 thoughts on “Authority Websites: How Big is Too Big?
  1. Slim Jim says:

    Great Post!

    I’ve tried a few of your tips, & by adding a video to your blog post (hosted on YouTube, etc…) will actually follow your Google SERP ranking.

    I have a single blog post that ranks for two words, (#1 in Google SERP (22,000,000)for almost a year now), I was already ranking great & I re-read my blog post, thought I should have added a bit more info. So, instead of edits to my already high ranking blog post, I simply added a YouTube video, & pasted a backlink in the video description to my blog post.

    Now I have a video & blog post that ranks #1 in Google SERP. :)

    The blog post is also ranked #1 in Google-Images with the Image ALT-Text.

    So, now that’s three #1 spots on the net, for a single blog post.

    What’s funny is, I wasn’t trying to get that specific blog post to rank for anything. That single blog post is what started me on my quest for all things SEO!

  2. Slim Jim:

    Gotta love the beauty of You tube and blended search…

    Glad you like today’s post and as always, thanks for commenting.

  3. Slim Jim says:


    I never really thought about pretty URL’s, until I read about them here on your blog. I’m working on another CMS site, & this is #1 on my list, I’ve actually got about 90% of my links cut in half (from the defualt url’s).

    I’ve removed everything so my URL’s look like:

    (root + blog-post-title)

    Thanks, again for posting this great seo info.

    No joke, I check this blog everyday for the great content that you always post.

    Now, If only I could get Google-Reader to update with your new blog post, in real time (lol) :)

  4. That’s a good idea for a widget.. Preferred Real-Time RSS! Hmmmm

  5. Webmaster are always looking forward to have a good ranking in able to have a good reputation for their sites. The higher your ranking is the better reputation that you can get.

Comments are closed.